21
Why we compete
As we wrap up our Winter term at the Oregon MBA, I’m proud to reflect back on the efforts of our teams that took their ideas ‘on the road’ and across borders to socialize their ideas and gather valuable feedback from judges and peers. If no business plan survives first contact with customers, then you cannot overstate the value of getting out the building to share your idea with the world.
Many will say that the ‘business plan’ is dead and that business plan competitions are a lost cause. We at the Lundquist College of Business respectfully disagree. Writing a business plan and putting together an investor pitch is not a waste of valuable MBA time. Rather, those activities are a forcing function for students to integrate the business model they’ve designed, the customer development they’ve done, and the core MBA functions of finance and strategy together in a well-communicated package.
We send Oregon MBAs to these competitions to expand student perspectives and share in the joy of competition. When our teams compete, they get the type of hands-on learning that builds human capital for the future. No amount of classwork can prepare you for the challenges that come from unknown judges and competition from other well-developed ideas. Students learn from one another, sharing the experiences of the tough judges, travel, and experiences of a student entrepreneur. Whether it’s in Bangkok Thailand, Louisville, Winnipeg, or Portland, the outcome of these competitions is the same – experiences that shape ideas and outcomes for a students’ career.
Feature image: Team ‘Ale Mail’ in Winnipeg
11
Winning the Day @ Global Venture Labs in Austin, TX
The following was announced and written by Nathan Lillegard, Center Director for the Lundquist Center for Entrepreneurship on May 9, 2015:
I am pleased to share news about a successful campaign by our students from the Oregon MBA and Oregon Law School at the Global Venture Labs Investment Competition (formerly MOOT Corp) this past weekend at the University of Texas at Austin.
For the first time ever the University of Oregon placed 2 teams in the semifinal round. To put that in perspective, there were 33 teams that started the competition on Thursday, with 10 advancing to the semis. That’s 20% of the top 30% representing the UO – not bad! This is the best showing for our program at this competition in many years. I couldn’t be more proud of their efforts.
Our teams:
Airfit – Second year MBAs Cynthia Sandall and Ty Manegold have brought a concept to life. The idea, fitness facilities in airports behind TSA, is simple. The execution of the concept and the actual market launch of the concept is quite complicated. I applaud their tenacity of research and the way they’ve leveraged every possible LCB class project to gather amazing customer research and build a great plan. You will see the first location in SFO within a year and JFK shortly thereafter. They’ve made this real and are launching. Bravo!
Cricket Flours – Charles Wilson (2015 JD) and Omar Ellis (2015 MBA), with help early on from Paul Butler (JD/MBA) successfully pitched their cricket based protein powder business to the judges in a way that focused on their deep understanding of customers, the business model, and their markets while far overcoming anyone’s “You want me to eat what?” objections. Their best customer validation? How about a half dozen or so orders from judges and other competitors over the past 2 days? They have a rapidly growing business that will be a great success story.
I thank the many staff and faculty members who have helped our teams develop into poised and confident entrepreneurs. Specifically, I want to thank Allan Cochrane, my co-instructor for MGMT 625 and the Venture Startup courses. Al has logged many miles and hours helping prepare ‘investor ready’ teams. Additional thanks goes to Michael Crooke and John Hull who have given these teams countless tips and spent a good deal of time coaching them individually and as teams. I should also recognize the contributions of Randy Swangard, who was in attendance as the head of the GVLIC rules committee and without whom the program to do all of this wouldn’t exist. Every faculty member who has taught any class to these fine students should give themselves a pat on the back, as the overall education of our students is outstanding and it shows when we’re up against some of the brightest minds in the world and come out successful.
Although their journey ended in the semi-finals (the competition is tough and only 4 of 10 teams advanced) I am 100% confident that we’ll soon have two more inspiring stories of Oregon MBA led student startups. Success at these competitions shows the depth of research they’ve done and their commitment to making their ideas real. At the end of the day, that’s why we (faculty and staff) do what we do – to inspire students to be the best they can be and reach higher than they might think they can. That is Winning the Day, that is what we do.
11
The first Saturday in May was a busy day! Not only was it the Kentucky Derby but it was also the Spring Scrimmage game for our football team (Oregon won). However, the most important event was the second annual Pitch Stream hosted by the Fertilab Thinkubator, a local resource network for the Eugene entrepreneurial community. Pitch Stream was held at the Wildish Theater in Springfield and awarded over $5000 in cash and prizes for the winners. 16 companies were selected to present a 7 minute pitch (3 minutes for Q & A) about the awesomeness of their value propositions. Kimmy Gustafson, last year’s winner, Fertilab community manager, and start up CEO, kept the event running smoothly and on time. Not a small task for entrepreneurs. Kimmy and her husband Nathan (both UO alms) started Manage My Co-Op, a software platform to ease the coordination of orders for buying clubs. We were lucky enough to have our two MBA Venture Track teams complete: Cricket Flours and AirFit. I am not sure if it was the luck of the draw or a deliberate arrangement, but Charles B. Wilson started the contest off with a fantastic presentation promoting the health benefits of adding milled crickets to your diet and Cynthia Sandall ended the competition by introducing gyms in airports post security to increase your healthy options during layovers. Capitalizing on primacy and recency effects, Cynthia took home the People’s Choice award and Charles Wilson took home the grand prize of $2500 in cash. Way to represent Oregon Entrepreneurship, teams!!
Oregon is quite an outdoorsy and health conscious state. But, who says that work and travel need to get in the way of that? Oregon MBAs and JDs see the potential for everyone to live healthy lives amongst the ever increasing busyness of our daily schedules. Having the opportunity to exercise over layovers will disrupt the traditional use of time at major airports and help you not miss your daily workout. And, using crickets as a source of protein in your everyday diet is not only more environmentally sustainable than traditional sources, but provides the opportunity for people to increase the protein and nutrient density in everyday foods. (Don’t worry, the crickets are milled so fine you can’t even tell they are there. Once you try it you will get over any ick factor you may have. Trust me!)
The Entrepreneurship Center at the University of Oregon produces companies in all shapes and sizes. With help from the community, I know these teams will make it far! What is up next for these amazing ventures is the University of Texas at Austin Global Venture Labs Investment Competition held May 7-9, 2015. Cricket Flours and AirFit will go up against the best graduate venture teams in the country. However, the academic framework, extensive faculty support of Nathan Lillegard and Al Cochrane, and individual drive will no doubt give our teams a fighting chance. If you are in Austin, swing on by the competition and introduce yourself. Who knows, you may be the next great Oregon Entrepreneur!
02
AirFit Competes at Cardinal Challenge @ U. of Louisville
After leaving Eugene on a 5:28 am flight, we arrived in Louisville, Kentucky, ready to pitch our company, AirFit, to the judges and audience at the Cardinal Challenge Business Plan Competition. We knew we were up for a challenge as most teams competing were involved in life-sciences, and the judges would have to completely shift their mindset for our presentation. Unlike our fellow teams with their latest-and-greatest diabetes monitor or a new surgical instrument, our product is simple to understand. AirFit is revamping the dreaded layover experience by placing gym and shower facilities into airport terminals, located behind security. While most teams spent a significant amount of the presentation explaining how their product was better than the alternatives, our feat was to explain all the financial costs associated with our endeavor and why we were the best team to bring this vision to reality.
Friday evening began with a social reception and introduction. During our candid and brief self-intro to all the other groups and advisors, AirFit was immediately well-received, garnering applause and supportive cheers upon the initial announcement of what we were trying to accomplish. Clearly AirFit’s value proposition was meeting the needs of many people in the crowd. Funneling this supportive energy, we took to the stage bright and early the next morning, unveiling AirFit to the world outside Oregon for its maiden flight. 15 minutes of uninterrupted presentation, followed by another 15 of Q&A, we delivered a solid performance.
The only team at the competition with just two founders, a completely different business model than any other company present, and having nothing to do with the deep fried chicken style concepts normally seen at this Kentucky competition, AirFit had the cards stacked against us. These uphill battles became apparent when we discovered we unfortunately did not make it onto the final round. Major challenges revolved around convincing judges to remain objective and not ask whether they, in fact, would use the product, but what the voice of the customer at large was telling us. According to our market research (tinyurl.com/AirFitSurvey) of over 200 respondents, polled mainly in airport or gym environments, more than 85% indicated an interest for AirFit’s services, and at even what price-point they would be willing to pay. Unfortunately these key data points fell on deaf ears and are an area of improvement in the presentation we plan on addressing in our next competition this spring.
While disappointed we did not win the competition, all of AirFit’s founders and team enjoyed the experience for what it was – a tremendous learning opportunity and one of the many rite-of-passages most new ventures must undergo. Our concept had open validation among individuals in the crowd, and even from competing teams. The ability to compete in such an environment is a fantastic opportunity in and of itself. Each team present in Louisville clearly contributed their own blood, sweat, and tears over the last few months to get to this point, only raising the overall caliber of the entire performance. The final outcome of the situation is that all AirFit members are ready to tackle the next presentation, next investor meeting, and next step involved in taking our company forward on the path to success. Namely, we are looking for one more individual with prior gym management experience to join the team in an operations role, and the next few months before graduation will be dedicated to this task.
09
Duck feet all over the WAC
Oregonians are generally averse to self-promotion. We’re a humble lot (mostly) that figure it’s better to let our achievements speak for themselves than spend time and energy seeking recognition. It’s something we do and part of the culture. But I’m going to step out of that mold for now and praise some of our students and community friends after witnessing the Willamette Angel Conference today.
First, I want to thank everyone who has helped bring the Matthew Knight Arena and Ford Alumni Center together. The WAC was hosted in the Guistina Ballroom at the Ford Alumni Center this year. Finally, the UO has a world-class facility to have formal events! Don’t get me wrong, the old EMU Ballroom and a couple of other facilities on campus are great. However, the modern and uniquely Oregon design of the FAC really stands out for people coming into town. Having Matt Arena right next door gives the East campus area a center of gravity that the whole university needed.
Second, let’s recognize all of the University of Oregon students and alumni involved in the Willamette Angel Conference. The list is long, so let’s bullet point for brevity:
- The Concept Stage winner was Orchid Health – A local Eugene company creating direct primary care clinics in medically under-served communities. Started by a one-year-ago grad and a soon-to-be graduate. That’s right, early twenty-somethings starting a health care company. Cool.
- Other Concept Stage companies representing UO ties:
- Dyscover.me: a start-up company targeting ERP of Human Resources co-founded by an Oregon MBA alumnus
- Manage my co-op: a husband/wife team of OMB (Marching Band) alumni building tools to enable group buying clubs for everything
- Blue Dog Mead, a well-established beverage company, was represented at the event by CEO and co-founder Simon Blatz. Keeping the dream alive and mead flowing.
- The Oregon MBA and other Lundquist College of Business students helped with the due diligence process and as volunteers for the event.
Dune Sciences, one of the five finalist companies has strong ties to the UO. The company was founded by John Miller and Jim Hutchison based on research from their lab in the Materials Science Institute at the University of Oregon. I know that this team has been working at this for a long time to bring their technology to market. Making it to the WAC Finals was a big accomplishment for them. I know that Dune Sciences is going to continue to grow and be a big UO and Eugene success story.
Finally, let’s talk about RAIN. The Regional Accelerator and Innovation Network is finally up and running in Eugene. Joe Maruschak, a UO art major and game development entrepreneur, is taking the reins of the local node of this program. Joe is a community builder who understands the role an accelerator and incubator can play in developing an ecosystem for startups. Good things are on the horizon. The support that the Office for Research Innovation and Graduate Education has provided getting RAIN going has been invaluable. Associate Vice President for Research & Innovation Patrick Jones has brought his experiences building a similar community in Tucson, Arizona, and at the U. of Arizona to bear to help make this a reality. Without this kind of fundamental support in place, building a thriving entrepreneurial community is harder. With this high-level support, we’re all pulling together to improve the community and build a place where students can stay after they graduate.
So be on the lookout for more great things happening here in Eugene. You may need to ask to hear about it. We’ll be busy letting our successes speak for themselves.
18
San Francisco, Day 1
Our trip to the Bay Area last week was action packed, to say the least. After a long drive from Eugene to San Francisco, we had an evening to rest up before our first day of business visits. FSAC split from the main group to conduct their own visits (look for another post soon!), LCE and CSBP hit the ground running with the executives from Ticketfly. CFO Bob Komin is a relatively new addition to the Ticketfly team, but as a UO undergrad alum, he was more than happy to share his experience with our group, and give us advice on how to maximize the power of our MBA.
Klout was second on our agenda, and provided us with a fantastic visit that helped us understand what it’s like to be part of the San Francisco startup scene. Students enjoyed learning about Klout’s mission of “empowering every person by unlocking their influence.” During our visit, we also learned about the company’s formation, and its goals for the near future. Students also learned about the importance of social media in today’s society and the influence each Facebook and Twitter user can generate through sharing content. The reward-based gamification of social media via Klout was also very interesting, as it provides incentive for individuals to target their online interactions in order to achieve personal gain.
The next startup on our schedule was Dropcam. At Dropcam, we observed a great example of “recognizing business opportunities”, as the co-founders explained how they sort of fell into their company by initially trying to help out their parents. They then went on to explain the challenges of ensuring that their product could add value for their customers, and the difficulties they faced as they tried to segment markets, and straddle the line between producing hardware and providing software for their customers.
After Dropcam, we visited Equilibirum Capital, a visit that has been highlighted in detail here. Then we were off to the Capital One Innovation Center for an interactive group exercise with Josh Greenough, another UO alum. Josh focused a great deal on the innovation that is taking place nowadays with the increasing prevalence of mobile technology and transactions. He also discussed the role his team plays at Capital One, which is intriguing because they serve as an incubator inside of a much larger banking entity– two groups with very different levels of risk tolerance.
Although our first day was not finished yet (still on the docket was a wonderful dinner at the Century Club), our official business visits were complete. And in spite of the hectic scheduling, I think that everyone felt stimulated by the fast pace and excitement of San Francisco and its rapidly evolving tech environment, and hungry for more (and also that dinner at the Century Club!).
11
The following post was written by Rob Woltil (LCE 2013), regarding the trip he took to Thailand with for the Bangkok Business Challenge, with his Real Energy teammates, Joe Wright (LCE 2013) and KaLynn Alley (Law, 2013).
Coming to the University of Oregon to get my MBA, I knew that there would be fun times and extraordinary opportunities awaiting me over the next two years. However, I did not foresee that I would be in Bangkok, delivering a passionate monologue about an investment vehicle that specializes in energy efficiency retrofits to a room that consisted of over 300 Thais and an assortment of business school professors and students that covered over 20 countries and an equal amount of languages. This was the elevator pitch. It was the first formal introduction of the teams that would be competing in the Bangkok Business Challenge. Ideas ranged from a French bakery chain to floating solar farms for specific use in the mining industry, which was presented by a team of Australian EMBA’s. The crowd loved every part of the elevator pitch competition from the seamless banter provided by our two hosts Tony and Troy to the big clock counting from 99 to zero on 16 teams from all over the world. As a Meyers-Briggs identified introvert without an affinity for public speaking, I was content making it through the pitch without freezing or passing out.
The elevator pitch set the table for the competition as it was fast paced, fun, and competitive. We presented a grand total of three times over the weekend: once as a warm-up round, once for the semi-finals, and once in the wildcard playoff. Despite receiving positive feedback on our team and idea, we failed to advance to the finals. This disappointment was quickly quelled by two of our judges giving us contact information to several international investment companies and hedge funds that they believed would be interested in our idea and an opportunity to attend the awards ceremony.
And this was no ordinary awards ceremony. To begin, every team gathered at their venture’s trade show booth, and a representative of the King of Thailand himself came around to every team to get a one minute pitch of what it was that we do. Thankfully, my teammate Joe Wright took the lead and nailed the explanation. The King’s representative walked away nodding his head, I’d like to think it was a nod that said, “Well done Oregon, well done.” The second part of the awards ceremony was held on the Chao Phraya River as part of a river cruise. Prizes were passed out as we dined, danced, and admired the great city of Bangkok with 200 of our newest friends.
Words cannot express how amazing this trip was for us. We owe a debt of gratitude to Sasin Graduate Institute of Chulalongkorn University, the Lundquist Center for Entrepreneurship, and our vast Oregon network of people who helped, critiqued, and mentored us through this process. While we missed out on the finals this time, we will be working our tails off to see them in a month at the New Venture Championship in Portland. Until then…GO DUCKS!!!
27
EndorsEase on the Competition Circuit in Cincinnati
19
Utter disappointment. There was really no other way to describe how we felt when another team’s name was called from our track to advance to the finals. We felt so good about our presentation, we got great feedback from everyone sitting in our room, and yet that day we came up just short. We had no time to feel sorry for ourselves, however, because within the next hour we would receive feedback from the judges and then compete in the Fast Pitch (Elevator Pitch) competition. The feedback we received from the judges quite possibly made the loss worth it. They expressed how difficult their decision was and reassured us that just because we hadn’t advanced didn’t mean we weren’t going to make Red Duck a successful business. After a few pointers, a few handshakes, and a few business cards, we headed over to the Fast Pitch competition.
07
Want to know more about Red Duck Ketchup, the recent champions of the Graduate Venture Quest competition? Here is a quick profile of the team, their business plan, and the ketchups’ successes so far!
Who is Red Duck?
- Kurt “More Meatloaf” Barajas (JD/MBA 2013): Financial whiz and negotiation specialist with concentration in business law.
- Karen “Crazy for Veggie Burgers” Bonner (MBA 2013): Background in finance and corporate strategy, product development specialist, food nerd.
- Shannon “Pass the Cajun Tots” Oliver (MBA 2013): Experience at food startup companies, operations expert, concentration in sustainability.
- Jess “Don’t Call Them Freedom Fries” Zutz (JD/MBA 2014): Background in restaurant and kitchen management, branding, marketing, and social media professional.
What is Red Duck Ketchup?
When was the last time you were excited about ketchup? As adults, we realized that ketchup’s cachet has faded as our palates have matured. We started Red Duck Ketchup as a specialty foods company based to re-introduce the world to ketchup through our line of artisan condiments and our quirky West Coast brand.
Why ketchup?
During the Oregon MBA’s Engaging Asia experiential learning trip, the four of us found we shared passions for travel and food. After many conversations lamenting the fact that our grocery stores back home don’t carry many products featuring our favorite exotic flavors, we realized there’s a gap in the market. We decided to remedy this by combining our business backgrounds with our foodie expertise to create a line of artisan ketchups.
How did we develop the business?
After returning from our trip to Asia in September, the four of us enrolled in New Venture Planning, part of the Lundquist Center for Entrepreneurship’s Venture Launch sequence. This course gave us the opportunity to transform our vision into a solid business plan. We had opportunities to meet with successful entrepreneurs and other mentors to guide us and help us prepare a defensible business strategy.
During the course of the term, we fine-tuned our recipes and did blind taste tests against other specialty ketchups. Our biggest tasting event happened at the beloved Bagel Day, a weekly LCB event that supplies grad students with snacks and coffee. We were able to bring in fresh French fries and conduct a head-to-head blind taste test of our three ketchups (Classic, Spicy, and Curry) against three similar competitors. After 52 people completed our market research survey, we crunched the numbers and were pleased to see that Red Duck Ketchup crushed all three competitors! This was a pivotal moment in the term, as it provided us with some basic customer validation and a compelling chart for our business plan.
We then had the opportunity to participate in the OMBA’s Venture Quest Competition, where we won the elevator pitch and business plan competition, securing almost $2000 to start funding our business. Over winter break, we worked to refine our business plan and begin positioning our company for success in the future. With the start of winter term now here, we’ll be moving on to Venture Startup 1, the next phase in the venture launch sequence. Quack!