Through Martin Luthers’ attacks on the three walls of Romanist Christianity and his Fool’s song, Luther humorously explains the corrupt and false pure inventions and unjust power that the Romanists held over all Christians. The Romanists created three walls in the Christian Church. These walls are used for protection of their beliefs and no one has been able to reform them. “When pressed by the temporal power they have made decrees and declared that the temporal power had no jurisdiction over them, but that, on the contrary, the spiritual power is above the temporal.” “When the attempt is made to reprove them with the Scriptures, they raise the objection that only the pope may interpret the Scriptures.” “If threatened with a council, their story is that no one may summon a council but the pope.” (pages 90-91).
Luther says that they created these walls so that Romanists can practice all of the “wickidness” that we see today. Luther explains that these three walls help to give and keep the power strictly in the hands of the Romans and all that is wrong, blasphemous, and greedy. Luther explains how the Romanists contain all of the power within these three walls saying, “In addition, they have given the pope full authority over all decisions of a council, so that it is all same whether there are many councils or no councils. They only deceive us with puppet shows and sham fights. They fear terribly for their skin in a really free council. They have so intimidated kings and princes with this technique that they believe it would be an offense against God not to be obedient to the Romanists in all their knavish and ghoulish deceits.” (91).
Luther states that we should begin by breaking down the first wall. He says that all Christians are of the spiritual estate and that there is no difference between Christians and the popes and priests that claim to be all Christians superiors and deem themselves the spiritual estate. Luther argues that we are all the spiritual estate because there are no boundaries between Christians and God Himself, contrary to what the Romanists have told Christians. Luther refers to Paul in 1 Corinthians 12:12-13 and says that “we are all one body, yet every member has its own work by which it serves the others. This is because we all have one baptism, one gospel, one faith, and are all Christians alike; for baptism, gospel, and faith alone make us spiritual and a Christian people.” Luther also references Peter in 1 Peter 2:9, explaining that essentially we are all priests through baptism. He also quotes Revelation (Revelation 5:9-10) saying, “Thou hast made us be priests and kings by blood.” Luther goes on to quote Romans and John scriptures, among others. Luther quotes John 6:45, saying that all Christians are to be taught by God. He interprets this as giving all Christians the right and opportunity to decipher scriptures and their meanings for themselves, as it pertains to their own individual relationship with God. Luther goes on to explain that the Romanists have no reasoning to their beliefs. They claim that priests and the pope were given the right to be the only ones able to read and decode scripture because St. Peter was given the keys. However, Luther says that the keys were not given to Peter alone, but the entire community, making the Romanists’ viewpoint invalid. Lastly, Luther claims that the third wall falls on its own as the previous two have been demolished. Luther quotes Matthew 18:15-17, explaining that the scripture says that if you sin against your brother, you are to go and tell your brother, and your brother alone. If he does not listen to you, take one or two others. If he does not listen to them, tell it to the church. If he does not listen to the church, consider him a heathen. It is clear that all sins should be discussed between sinners and the church, such as the popes and priests, should be the last people you consult. Luther says that the pope is an “offense to Christendom.” It is clear with his references to scriptures that using the ability to read and interpret scripture on his own, which is ironically and humorously what the Romanists fight against, is his favorite tactic when taking down the Romanists’ walls of Christianity.
Luther also breaks down the Romanists walls of Christianity by creating scenarios through storytelling, comparisons, name-calling, and humor. He humorously refers to these Romanist walls as “paper walls.”
Martin Luther uses his humor, sarcasm, wit, and intelligence to mock and correct the corrupt ways of the Romanist church in his fool’s song. Martin Luther introduces his fool’s song, saying, “Now, although I am too insignificant a man to make propositions for the improvement of this dreadful state of affairs, nevertheless I shall sing my fool’s song through to the end and say, so far I am able, what could and should be done, either by the temporal authority or by a general council” (95). His proposals in this fool’s song that I found to be most damaging to the Romanist Christian church are:
(1) Every prince, every noble, every city should henceforth forbid their subjects to pay annates to Rome and should abolish them entirely.
(3) The council of Nicaea should be restored and no bishop’s cloak and no confirmation of any dignity shall be secured from Rome.
(9)The pope should have no authority over the emperor, except the right to anoint and crown him at the altar just as a bishop crowns a king
(17) Certain penalties or punishments of canon law should be abolished, too, especially the interdict
(23) The brotherhoods, and for that matter, the indulgences, letters of indulgence, butter letters, mass letters, dispensations, and everything of that kind, should be snuffed out and brought to an end. There is nothing good about them.
These are the most damaging because they are frequent wrongful actions of the Romanist Christian Church or they are large advances to the ideal Christianity in Martin Luther’s opinion in his educated experience.