Experimental Zoogeography of Islands: The Colonization of Empty Islands. Daniel Simberloff and E.O. Wilson (1968)

This study was of the events following a defaunation event on six islands of the coast of the Florida Keys, each island consisting of one or several mangroves. Simberloff and Wilson suggest that given time the population of species on each island will reach a predictable dynamic equilibrium consisting of a similar but constantly changing cast of species.

The issues I found with this research were several. The authors conducted only a single survey of each island plus two controls before the experiment began and used this is an assumed average species number on each island, a sample size far too small from which to draw any conclusions. Beginning from this survey, any information they glean about average species numbers may match up to an anomalous “average” and wrongfully confirm their theories. Throughout the experiment, the collection of data was too infrequent given the ephemeral nature of many of the species involved. The experiment also ended before any of the islands populations were found to have arrived at a dynamic equilibrium, so any similarity between the pre-defaunation survey and the final survey could be a case of a broken clock being “right” twice a day, in this case, right meaning supporting the theory put forward in the paper. Finally, there is no indication that the two control islands were surveyed more than once before and once after the experiment, which would have given a much clearer view of the properties and typical variance of a dynamic equilibrium.

Aside from the conduct of the experiment, I found the writing to be a bit lacking. I would have found technical details on how the surveys were conducted, and where each island was located relative to a source and each other to be helpful in filling out my understanding of the theory.

My feeling toward this essay isn’t that the authors’ theory is incorrect, it’s that the way the experiment was conducted left didn’t find conclusive enough evidence to confirm it.

41 thoughts on “Experimental Zoogeography of Islands: The Colonization of Empty Islands. Daniel Simberloff and E.O. Wilson (1968)

  1. Darrylrobertas

    Relaxing can help keep you healthy, in both your body and mind, helping you recover from the everyday stresses that life throws at you. Luckily, no matter how busy you are, it’s simple to play bloxorz for chilling and also how to best relax.

    Reply
  2. brianwilson

    From turn-by-turn instructions and real-time traffic updates to alternative routes and estimated arrival times, this app ensures you can navigate with confidence and make informed decisions on the road. Mapquest directions

    Reply
  3. ClearHolidays™

    Your critique of the study “Experimental Zoogeography of Islands: The Colonization of Empty Islands” by Daniel Simberloff and E.O. Wilson provides a detailed examination of the research methods and potential limitations in the paper. You’ve raised valid concerns about the study’s design, data collection, and the overall clarity of the writing.

    Your observation regarding the small sample size used for the initial survey and the potential for an anomalous “average” is a significant point. Small sample sizes can indeed lead to skewed or unreliable results. Similarly, your criticism of the infrequent data collection in relation to the dynamic nature of species populations highlights the importance of capturing more frequent snapshots to observe changes over time accurately.

    Your mention of the experiment ending before the islands’ populations reached a dynamic equilibrium raises questions about the study’s timing and whether it allowed sufficient time for the desired outcomes to manifest.

    Furthermore, your desire for more technical details on survey methods and island locations demonstrates your engagement with the research process and the importance of transparency in scientific studies.

    Your concluding sentiment, where you express doubt not about the theory itself but the experimental evidence provided, reflects a balanced and critical approach to evaluating scientific research.

    Your critique effectively highlights the areas where the study could be improved and encourages a more rigorous scientific investigation.

    Sincerely,
    https://clearholidays.com

    Reply
  4. clamb

    I am an admin from the wheel spinner game website, and I want to thank you a lot because I shared a lot of valuable and helpful information. Please keep it up and I will always support you.

    Reply
  5. redactle

    Your comments are more appealing than the pleasure of playing redactle, the most popular game on the market right now that young people like me are looking for. I’ve never read anything like this before, but the premise you present is fascinating.

    Reply
  6. Allen

    Explore and reinforce your knowledge of cybersecurity concepts with CompTIA PT0-002 Practice Questions. These practice questions are designed to simulate the format and content of the CompTIA PenTest+ certification exam, helping you assess your readiness and identify areas for improvement. Covering a range of topics such as penetration testing methodologies, vulnerability assessment, and ethical hacking techniques, these practice questions are an essential tool for aspiring cybersecurity professionals aiming to succeed in the PT0-002 exam.

    Reply
  7. Tyler Durden

    Coffee is part of so many people’s lives nowadays and many people start their day with a cup of coffee. Coffee is what can make a difference in a lot of people’s moods.
    blogamca

    Reply
  8. adsdlmk

    In the ever-evolving world of IT certifications, the HP HPE6-A85 exam is a crucial milestone for professionals aiming to validate their expertise in Aruba Certified ClearPass Expert (ACCX) V6.7. Whether you’re an aspiring candidate or a seasoned professional looking to update your credentials, understanding and utilizing HP HPE6-A85 New Dumps Questions can significantly enhance your preparation strategy.

    Reply
  9. Anthony

    In the game a little to the left players are tasked with organizing various objects to achieve the best visual arrangement. The objective is to bring order to the items on the screen in each level. Players must use their creativity and problem-solving skills to find the most satisfying configuration. It’s a relaxing and enjoyable game that rewards careful thought and attention to detail.

    Reply
  10. Ethan Hunt

    I enjoy playing video games immensely. I can only unwind after a day of labor in this manner. I wish to immerse myself in the game and appreciate its enchanted universe. Therefore, many thanks for the game happy wheels. You suggested.

    Reply
  11. robertjohn

    Francis O’Leary’s Working Title explores the intricacies of modern life through compelling narratives and rich characters. For students seeking the best accounting assignment writing service, top options include MyAssignmentHelp, UK Assignments Help, and Accounting Assignment Help. These services offer expert guidance, ensuring high-quality, original work tailored to your specific needs, helping you excel in your accounting studies and achieve academic success.

    Reply
  12. androidboxpk

    Gone are the days when television was limited to a handful of channels broadcast over the airwaves. Today, streaming services, on-demand content, and internet connectivity have revolutionized how we consume media. The Etisalat Android TV Box embodies this evolution by seamlessly integrating traditional TV channels with a host of online streaming platforms.

    Reply
  13. Nadia Moore

    Francis O’Leary’s Working Title delves into the complexities of modern existence with engaging stories and vivid characters, much like the engaging gameplay of Monkey Mart, where strategy and resource management are key. For students navigating their accounting assignments, services like MyAssignmentHelp and UK Assignments Help provide tailored support, ensuring they can effectively manage their academic responsibilities as in Monkey Mart, where balancing resources is essential for success. Embracing these tools can lead to greater academic achievements, allowing students to shine in their studies while enjoying the thrill of managing a virtual store.

    Reply
  14. SqUAD

    This information has me giddy! The author has clearly taken considerable care to deliver insightful and helpful information. I couldn’t resist booking a session as a kind gift for a friend after learning about SEV Laser. The encounter filled them with immense joy! After reading so many positive reviews and seeing how much fun people had with their sessions, I felt compelled to express my enthusiasm. Anyone considering Laser Hair Removal in Austin should definitely check out SEV Laser. Thank you for sharing your excellent content.

    Reply
  15. Elettra Tempocasa

    Elettra Tempocasa bietet umfangreiche Immobilienlösungen in Italien. Um Elettra Tempocasa auf Ihrem Mobilgerät oder PC zu nutzen, laden Sie die App aus dem App Store oder Google Play Store herunter und installieren Sie sie.

    Reply
  16. Mel

    What a fantastic read! I truly appreciate the effort and thoughtfulness the author has put into this content. It’s refreshing to see such valuable insights shared within the community. I’ve been following the conversations here, and it’s clear that many others feel the same way. The experiences shared are genuinely inspiring. As someone who believes in the power of AI SEO Services, I see how they can revolutionise smarter digital marketing strategies. If you’re looking to elevate your content, check out this excellent resource on Video SEO. Cheers!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *