Land

2023

It Takes A Swarm
Native pollinators need our attention — Willamette Valley residents are up to the challenge.
It Takes A Swarm
Land

2023

Native pollinators need our attention — Willamette Valley residents are up to the challenge.
The long-horned bee, native to North America, is just one of many species that are critical for pollinating plants in the Pacific Northwest.
Words by Ella Hutcherson | Photos by Isaac Wasserman

Related story: Collecting For A Cause

I am slightly lost on the third floor of Onyx Bridge, a science building on the University of Oregon’s campus. There’s a lot to look at — announcements tacked to bulletin boards and research posters hung haphazardly from walls — but only one thing will tell me if I’m in the right place.

Finally, I see it: the window that allows a view into Rebecca Hayes’ office, the glass dotted in hand-painted bees and flowers. When I’d reached out about a meeting to discuss Rebecca’s work in the UO Ponisio Lab, which focuses in part on bee conservation, she’d told me to look for that window.

The second eye-catcher is Rebecca herself. A 27-year-old PhD candidate, Rebecca is wearing a bright smile behind a pair of round glasses and a tie-dyed T-shirt, the pastels of which compliment her lavender hair, that sports a drawing of a bee.

I can tell straight away that this person loves bees. What I would eventually come to learn is that this love, also harbored by many others, is a deep, crucial and complicated thing.

Once I’m inside the office, Rebecca tells me she did not paint the bees on the windows herself. She’s not artistic that way, but if she ever decides to give it a try, she’d want to add a long-horned bee.

 

She pulls up a YouTube video on her iPhone, turning the phone to show me. On screen, the male long-horned bee’s massive antenna curls around the female’s, stroking up and down. Basically, it’s bee porn.

“The males have antennae that are as long as the female’s body, and they exchange pheromones when they’re mating,” Rebecca explains. “It was just very sensual for such a weird little bug. It struck my fancy.” 

Always interested in science as a child, Rebecca wanted to be an explorer when she grew up. Realizing that wasn’t a lucrative career option, she majored in biology as an undergraduate, and joined the Ponisio Lab in 2021. Now, Rebecca spends much of her time searching for bees, netting them and dissecting them in the lab.

“If I describe the work I do in the field to a child, sometimes they don’t believe that it’s a real job,” Rebecca says. “It’s a fun way to reconnect with that youthful energy of running around with a butterfly net, seeing what you can grab.” 

Rebecca Hayes stands with her arms crossed in front of her a very small smile on her face. She stands behind a window that is decorated with many bright bee and plant drawings.
“I guess I just think they are really cute,” says Rebecca Hayes, regarding her love of bees. Rebecca works in the University of Oregon Ponisio Lab, where she focuses on understanding gut microbes in bees and their correlation to bee health.
The Ponisio Lab’s work involves collaborating with landowners to improve management practices in the timber industry for bee community health, and also examines how plants and their pollinators come back after high-severity wildfires. The lab is run by Lauren Ponisio, an assistant professor of biology at the UO whose science focuses on community ecology, data science and wild bee conservation.

Rebecca teaches me that bees are not a singular creature. There are hundreds of different species. Some are native to North America, like the long-horned bees copulating on Rebecca’s screen. But when most of us think of bees, we think honeybees, which are non-native, brought to this continent in the 1600s. When we try to understand pollinators in our river valley and beyond, that’s an important distinction.

On my next outing to learn more about this distinction between bees and why it matters, I find myself in the middle of an oak savannah — Mt. Pisgah, an arboretum just southeast of Eugene. Here, the bees are not skewered on pins. They are flying among the local plants and animals. I wonder if any of these bees are long-horned bees.

A light yellow, dead long-horned bee is on a pin. Its horns are over a third of the size of its body.
A bright metallic purple colored, dead cobalt blue mason bee on a pin.
A fluffy yellow and black, dead Morrison's Desert Bumblebee is pinned. A mustard colored pouch of pollen is on its back leg.
Three specimens of native Oregon bees displayed in the Oregon Bee Lab at Oregon State University. The summer long-horned bee, left, visits flowers in the daisy family, such as sunflowers. Scientists are enamored with the long-horned bee’s sexual ritual. Mason bees, like the cobalt blue mason bee in the center, are solitary pollinators that use mud to build their nests. Morrison’s desert bumblebee, right, found across the west, has declined 82.6% over the last ten years, according to Xerces Society.
Three specimens of native Oregon bees displayed in the Oregon Bee Lab at Oregon State University. The summer long-horned bee, top, visits flowers in the daisy family, such as sunflowers. Scientists are enamored with the long-horned bee’s sexual ritual. Mason bees, like the cobalt blue mason bee in the center, are solitary pollinators that use mud to build their nests. Morrison’s desert bumblebee, bottom, found across the west, has declined 82.6% over the last ten years, according to Xerces Society.
Luckily, I am with August Jackson, the interpretive coordinator at Mt. Pisgah and a self-taught bee expert. August, a tall, soft-spoken man with a blond bun and beard, created a guide titled The Bees of the Willamette Valley: A Comprehensive Guide to Genera. He estimates that nearly 800 bee species live in Oregon. 

The Oregon Bee Atlas, an effort to catalog Oregon’s bee populations, has identified around 650 wild bee species in the state, and August expects that at least 100 more uncataloged bee species are out there. Native Oregon pollinators include species like western leafcutter bees, western bumblebees, blue orchard bees and, of course, long-horned bees. They come in various shapes, colors and sizes, and have different behaviors and timelines when it comes to nesting, interacting and pollinating. 

“There’s an extraordinary diversity,” August says, “and it’s one that people just aren’t really aware of.”

Native bees face several environmental obstacles, including habitat loss, pesticides, disease and invasive species, like honeybees. The loss of native bees, critical to native plant and crop pollination, would degrade the Willamette Valley’s rich ecology and natural beauty. Fortunately, across the river valley and in neighboring regions, scientists, conservationists and community members work to discover native bees’ whereabouts, maintain their well-being and enjoy their continued presence in our region. 

August says it was at Mt. Pisgah that his interest in bees blossomed ten years ago. 

August was exploring the region and admiring the flowers there when he noticed types of bees he’d never seen before. When he tried to look them up to identify them, there weren’t a lot of resources available to do so. 

The origins of his current work were “born out of an interest in what I was seeing, and the fact that I couldn’t find a lot of information about it,” he says. “I was just kind of stubborn about that.”

A decade later, August’s titles include bee taxonomist, educator, photographer and consultant.

He is interested in species distribution, specifically the more “oddball” pollinators that might fly under the radar. He finds out where bee populations are, as this species distribution provides information about the environment — the plants, the soil and the climate — and through comprehensive group efforts like that of the Oregon Bee Atlas, can inform conservation efforts through contributions to population data. 

Bee identification begins by collecting the specimen — August usually uses a net — and hand-pinning it. The bee is then placed under a microscope for identification, though dissection is sometimes necessary, as well. 

Different indicators separate bee species from one another. August says these can include the ratio of certain antennal segments to others, the shape of hairs or even parts of the male genitalia (male bees in certain groups lack other defining characteristics). After being identified, the collected bee is labeled and documented. 

This process matters, August says, because effective conservation of bees cannot happen without understanding there are hundreds of different species in Oregon and beyond. 

August wants bee identification to be accessible to anyone. He says this work has long been restricted to academic institutions, but that historically in entomology — the study of insects — community scientists contributed a lot of the major work. Educating citizens — whether it’s to feed their curiosity or to get them involved in citizen science groups — is a return to the roots of this kind of work. 

Though August wears many hats, all of his work centers building a sense of place for those who reside in the Willamette Valley, home to such a rich diversity of plants and insects. 

“The longer I live here,” August says, “the more I appreciate the ecology.”

This ecology is at risk. The primary threats to native pollinators now are habitat loss and native plant diversity loss. For example, logging and pesticide use contribute to these losses, and damage and fragment bees’ food sources.

Polly Habliston looks towards to the top shelf in her greenhouse. All around her tomato starts, succulents and other plants sit on a lower shelf.
Surrounded by starter plants, succulents, watering cans and glass jars, Polly Habliston works in her greenhouse, which she calls her “she shed.” Far from a shed, it is a clean, relaxing space in the middle of her garden.
The Ponisio Lab, where Rebecca works, aims to address these threats. Up the McKenzie River, just 30 miles from where I met August, sits Whitewater Ranch, a 100-acre blueberry farm in the McKenzie River Valley. There, in partnership with the Ponisio Lab, UO students restore habitat for pollinators through the Environmental Leadership Program (ELP).

The forested hills throughout the Mckenzie River Valley have been altered by years of timber harvesting, wildfire and herbicide application. In the summer of 2020, the Holiday Farm Fire ripped through nearly 175,000 acres of forest, settlements and farm fields, changing the landscape once again.

What remains is effectively a blank slate for native plants like yarrow, blue-thimble-flower and Oregon iris to take hold. The Ponisio Lab and the ELP are working together to enhance the disturbed land by planting and tracking the growth of pollinator-friendly, native plants.

When I meet Lauren Ponisio at Whitewater Ranch, she wears a beige top and khaki pants, offset by a pink ribbon on her hat and bright zinc sunscreen smeared across her cheeks. Clear cuts and burn residue surround us as far as the eye can see. In this landscape, both her lab and the ELP have small plots of successional habitat — the plants that develop following a disturbance.  Lauren tells me that pollinators would have a chance to thrive here if these plots could be replicated across the area.

“If in our timber plantations, we just restored a little bit of it, we’d have a lot of habitat over the whole landscape,” Lauren says. “And bees fly, so that’s very convenient!”

Unlike many of the native bee species Lauren seeks to aid through her lab’s work, honeybees are not an at-risk species. And like many United States residents, they’re relatively new to this land. Colonizers brought the European honeybee to our continent 400 years ago, and they spread westward. By the mid-20th century, honeybees had become critical crop pollinators. And now, their widespread popularity has made honeybees the symbol for a movement of which they are not actually a part, according to Rebecca.  

“When people hear ‘save the bees,’ usually, in their head, a picture of a honeybee pops up,” she says. 

Therefore, many people get into beekeeping out of an urgency to help pollinators, and purchase honeybees to pollinate their backyard ecosystems. Though well-intentioned, these kinds of purchases do not aid in the health of wild bees, and may even hurt them. Rebecca says honeybees carry diseases and parasites that can spread to native bees when they pollinate the same plants. Additionally, honeybees are generalists, meaning they will go to almost any flower and can exhaust the flower’s resources, out-competing the native bees, some of which are specialist pollinators with more specific needs.

Some beekeepers also keep bees native to North America, like the leafcutter or mason bee. “Mason bee” refers to any bee species in the genus Osmia. Unlike the honeybee, many species of mason bee are native, and they are all solitary creatures that use mud to build their nests. And where honeybees can pollinate about 5% of the flowers they visit, mason bees pollinate 95%.

“Mason bees are actually better pollinators,” says Polly Habliston, a retiree and the treasurer for the Lane County Beekeepers Association. “But the honeybees have the marketing experts and the advertising.”

In her sprawling garden in west Eugene, Polly keeps honeybees to produce honey. But she also keeps blue orchard bees, a native mason bee that is small, dark and metallic in appearance. After raising three boys, Polly became an empty-nester about 15 years ago and transitioned her energy into gardening. She feels passionately about maintaining a habitat for native bees as a way to help them out.

Nearly 80 tiny cardboard tubes are stacked in a wood box. At the entrance of one of the small tubes is a mason bee. The box is where it lives.
A mason bee enters its home as evening settles in Polly’s garden. Because of their nesting and pollinating habits, mason bees are easy and effective pollinators for backyard beekeeping.

Polly’s garden is rich with plants for native pollinators. It is a rare sunny day in the midst of an otherwise cold and wet April when Polly walks me through her backyard. Prior to other plants coming into bloom, her red dead nettle, a flowering weed, and hellebores, an early-blooming flower, are both good sources of food for the mason bees and other native and wild pollinators that often stop by.

 

“This whole massive hellebore can be covered with bumblebees,” she says, gesturing to a lush patch of the tender flower.

Other pollinator-friendly plants in Polly’s garden include heather, currants, honeysuckle, Indian plum and Oregon grapes. A small pond provides water for the mason bees to collect mud. 

“When you want to raise mason bees, you have to provide mud and you have to provide things for them to eat,” she says. “It’s pretty easy.”

Polly’s three mason bee houses are fixed to the interior awning of a detached garage in front of her garden. They are simple wooden boxes, each containing a hatching tube and nesting tubes. Inside a hatching tube are 50 cocoons, each containing a larva. 

Polly pours a few larva into the palm of her hand, and they roll around like little brown beans. When the larva hatch, they mate and find food. The females find mud, which they will pack into the reusable cardboard tubes in the mason bee houses to protect their eggs. They will continue this process, laying eggs and packing the nesting tubes with mud, for about four to six weeks. 

Polly’s backyard oasis serves as a respite, not just for native pollinators, but for herself, as well.  Although she may not be single-handedly saving the earth, she says it feels good to have a corner of it all to herself, a corner she can paint any way she likes. 

Polly steps through a gate in her blooming garden. Next to her is a yellow sign that says "bee crossing."
Polly is a Eugene resident, retiree and the treasurer of the Lane County Beekeeper Association. Polly’s home sits within a sprawling garden that she says would be unsuccessful without the help of the blue orchard bees she keeps.
In another painted corner of the world, Rebecca, her hair now light brown, leans over a countertop in one of the Onyx Bridge lab spaces, extracting the guts of a bumblebee with sharp tweezers. 

The Ponisio Lab looks at bee gut microbes, or the bacteria and other microorganisms that live in the digestive tract, to learn more about bee community health, as well as the health of individual bees. Rebecca says there isn’t much information out there about variation of gut microbes between bee species, so she is looking at a range of microbe communities in bees and then examining the patterns between species.

The bee currently on the counter has huge orange pollen sacs on either side of its body, which Rebecca removes prior to the procedure. 

“This is honestly like being murdered on your way home from Costco,” Rebecca says. “She had so much food.”

Using the tweezers, Rebecca removes the stinger from the bee’s abdomen, then extracts the gut, which comes out in one solid string, the color of gold. The next step is DNA extraction, so the lab can examine the contents of the gut. 

Rebecca says she likes to think she’s working to conserve wild bees, which can feel weird to say when so much of her work involves killing them and pulling out their innards. For that reason, she describes herself as more of a “bee evangelist” — someone who believes in the beauty of bees and wants to pass that on to those around her. 

I believe it, because I can feel the bee evangelism working on me. The longer I spend with the bee enthusiasts of the Willamette Valley, the more I find myself appreciating new details of the landscape. I now recognize some of the colorful, flowering plants that are healthy for native pollinators. When I see a mason bee house, I lean in to check for thick, brown mud filling the small tubes. And I feel a jolt of appreciation when I spot a fuzzy bumblebee buzzing through a patch of clover one cloudy afternoon in early May. 

I also witness the effort it takes to maintain a world that is healthy for bees. Back in the charred hills above Whitewater Ranch, Lauren and students with the University of Oregon Environmental Leadership Program, or ELP, are continuing their work in the burn plots, where they track the native species they’ve planted to see what’s surviving. Once the plants begin flowering, they’ll survey for pollinators, to see what variety of creatures are visiting the blooms. They’ll identify pollinators from other lab studies using the careful steps August described. And Rebecca, along with others in her lab, will take apart some of the creatures, too.

On a white paper, a string of a dead bees guts is pulled out of the back of the bee by a forceps. Another pair of forceps holds the bee down
Rebecca removes the bee’s gut from its abdomen. The procedure is a necessary step in the gut microbe sequencing conducted in the Ponisio Lab.

In order for any work of this nature to happen, the plants bees rely on must survive. Peyton Carl, an environmental science student in the ELP, is crouched over her patch of burn plot, examining the small, tentative seedlings emerging from the earth. In a brief pause from her work, Peyton tells me how rewarding she finds working in a habitat restoration project like this one, and how she hopes word about these projects can spread to other landowners outside Whitewater Ranch.

“I think the biggest thing is expanding the knowledge,” Peyton says, “and expanding everyone’s interest in native pollinators.” 

Before releasing the ELP teams to work in their plots, Lauren shared her pink and blue zinc sunscreens with the crew of students. Peyton has blended the two shades together, creating a soft lavender color now smeared across her nose and cheeks, a similar color to Rebecca’s hair when I first met her. I can’t help but think it’s the color of a flower a bee might like to visit.

A case of different size bumblebees inside of a glass display case.
Rebecca says collections of bees, like this case of bumblebees stored in the Ponisio Lab, are used in part to measure traits, like body size or intertegular distance (distance between bases of the wings on the thorax).

SOURCES

Main Sources

Rebecca Hayes — PhD candidate in UO Ponisio lab, rhayes7@uoregon.edu

August Jackson — bee conservationist and educator at Mt. Pisgah Arboretum, augustjackson@ecolingual.com

Polly Habliston — mason beekeeper, treasurer of LCBA, 541-206-2829

Lauren Ponisio — lead scientist, Ponisio Lab, lponisio@uoregon.edu

Peyton Carl — student in ELP project, interviewed in person

 

Background Sources

Peg Boulay — Coordinator of ELP habitat restoration project, boulay@uoregon.edu

Pam Levitt — LCBA, 541-554-4145

Marissa Lane-Massee — GE of ELP habitat restoration project, mlanemas@uoregon.edu

Rose McDonald — PhD student in UO Ponisio Lab, rmcdonal@uoregon.edu

 

Bibliography

Bee City USA. Bee City USA | Eugene, OR Website. (n.d.). https://www.eugene-or.gov/4321/Bee-City-USA

Braun, A. (2023, January 3). Making nature less predictable. bioGraphic. https://www.biographic.com/making-nature-less-predictable/

Environmental Leadership Program. Environmental Studies | Social Sciences. (n.d.-a). https://socialsciences.uoregon.edu/envs/hands-on/leadership#:~:text=Restoration%20and%20Research,%E2%80%94Whitewater%20Ranch%E2%80%94since%202014.

Gouy, K. (2022, December 9). Mason bees and how to care for them. One Green World. https://onegreenworld.com/mason-bee-care/#:~:text=Mason%20bees%20are%20excellent%20pollinators,to%20maintain%20year%20after%20year.

Hurt, A. (2022, April 22). Yes, some pollinators need saving – but honeybees are actually doing just fine. Discover Magazine. https://www.discovermagazine.com/planet-earth/yes-some-pollinators-need-saving-but-honeybees-are-actually-doing-just-fine

The Importance of Mud. Mason Bees Need Mud | Solitary Bee Raising Tips. (n.d.). https://crownbees.com/the-importance-of-mud/

Jackson, A. (n.d.). The Bees of the Willamette Valley: A Comprehensive Guide to Genera. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1sifHss1kn5HySuvdYTQuDFV5VlQbjjoT/view?fbclid=IwAR3ab5sUt9rcpSt2ZQ9ncwQ7J319hMaWlo6h5najPF8nIZMK2LTMLcNZF3Y

Kincaid, S. (n.d.). Common Bee Pollinators of Oregon Crops. Oregon Department of Agriculture. chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/https://www.oregon.gov/oda/shared/Documents/Publications/IPPM/ODABeeGuide.pdf

Mader, E. (2020, September 29). Social and solitary bees. SARE. https://www.sare.org/publications/managing-alternative-pollinators/chapter-three-a-brief-natural-history-of-bees/social-and-solitary-bees/#:~:text=Honey%20bees%20are%20probably%20the,that%20they%20also%20are%20social.

Mason Bee Life Cycle. Mason Bee Life-Cycle. (n.d.). https://crownbees.com/mason-bee-life-cycle/

Orchard mason bees. Orchard Mason Bees | Portland Nursery. (n.d.). https://www.portlandnursery.com/garden-projects/masonbees

Past Projects. Environmental Studies | Social Sciences. (n.d.-b). https://socialsciences.uoregon.edu/envs/hands-on/leadership/past-projects

Ponisio Lab. (n.d.). http://www.ponisiolab.com/

The why, what, when, where, who, how of pollination. Smithsonian Gardens. (2021, October 25). https://gardens.si.edu/gardens/pollinator-garden/why-what-when-where-who-how-pollination/#:~:text=Pollination%20is%20an%20essential%20part,later%20yields%20fruit%20and%20seeds.

Wild and Native Bees. Tualatin Valley Beekeepers Association – Other Bees. (n.d.). https://tvbabees.org/Other-Bees

Comments

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More stories

Blueberry Blues

Blueberry Blues

20232023A quarter million blueberry plants cover the fields of Whitewater Ranch along the McKenzie River at Leaburg, east of Eugene, Oregon. Fieldwork begins in early spring.Words by Eliza Lawrence | Photos by aj miccioShare via  On a sunny day in late July 2022,...

Sound Journey By Bike

Sound Journey By Bike

20232023A multi-use path allows walkers and bikers to cross between Springfield, Oregon, to the East of Interstate 5 and Eugene to the West. This stop along aj's commute is particularly dynamic as the sound of cars passing by melds with the rushing of water and...

Echoes of Amazon Creek

Echoes of Amazon Creek

20232023Photo courtesy Lauri Holts. Amazon Creek passes by many areas of Eugene before reaching the farmlands west of the city where it contributes to a wetland ecosystem important for agriculture, wildlife and recreation.By Riley O'ConnellShare via  General...