ENVS 607: Food Challenge (Fall 2015)

graduate student food challenge experiences

Category: SNAP Local Challenge

Eating Local on Snap: The intersection of access, labor, and leisure (update 3)

By my third  update I have stopped tracking the time I was spending on food and in looking back on the food we ate, most of what I cooked this week was from my fridge or my Winco trip with the local red barn groceries finding their way into my menu as snacks, ingredients, or in the case of the squash as I will detail below, failures! I never did make the winter vegetable slaw, but if you want to try it, it is truly amazing. I find that beets, carrots, and purple cabbage all keep really well in the fridge. Apples too.

Recipe: Grate one apple down to the core, along with a few carrots, and a red beet. Grate or finely chop some purple cabbage. Mix it with a small amount of pomegranate molasses, lemon olive oil, and balsamic vinegar (I have great friends who gift me with these types of things for birthdays and such). Eat and eat and eat and eat! So good! You can get creative and add chopped oranges too.

I didn’t get a chance to look at the Grit’s menus too closely, but what I did notice was that one dinner with a wine pairing is 55.00 per person. If I went there I would need to have both time and childcare and then I would need to be prepared to spend the equivalent to almost 2 weeks of my foodstamp budget.  While they might source their food locally, their wine list included wines from France. Furthermore, any establishment that carries that much wine is automatically implicated in labor issues as wineries locally and abroad are highly labor intensive and often make use of migrant labor. The website did not have the farms they source from, but I bet that Willamette Valley Food and Farm coalition would have that information in their brochure. I think the access and labor issues embedded in high end restaurants like this deserve way more critical analysis than I am able to do with this blog. Still, I think the local food movement that births restaurants such as this allows for upper class consumers to feel like they are making a conscientious difference by eating locally, while allowing them to ignore labor and accessibility issues embedded in their food. I don’t see anything progressive about this restaurant. The irony is it still has the Shamrock diner advertisement painted on the building, showing that at one time, one could get a meal there for 25 cents. Right now it is just another business that is adding to the quarterly rent increases I experience.  When I think about the Grit, I cannot help but wonder how long before I am priced out of the neighborhood I have lived in off and on my whole life.

So now that I have given you the recipe for a salad I intended to eat and talked a little bit about food I could never afford to eat, let me tell you a bit about what I did eat. (note, I the pictures all looked better while I was editing this post, for some reason they show up all wonky on the published version).

image4

Don’t let the squash fool you, it is still cold on the inside.

image7The first night I brought out some lamb that I had in the freezer. I had already prepped it with spices, finely chopped onion, dried cranberries, and parsley. I wanted to try a recipe for a lamb stew. It was really quick. I browned the lamb, added grated carrots, some sumac, cinnamon, and a bit of lemon juice, a can of chick peas, and some chicken broth. I topped it with fresh spinach and chopped almonds. Garnished it with yogurt. It was pretty good, though not something I will make again. I had a lot left over which leads me to my squash disaster.

So on Thursday night, I needed to use the squash, as I mentioned in my previous post, it was going bad. So I remembered that I had left over stew from the other day and I stuffed it all in the squash and put it in the oven. However, I couldn’t get it started until late, so it wasn’t done when we needed to eat. So I turned off the oven and we went to Café Yumm. I ended up spending 15 bucks, which as I learned previously is roughly equivalent to 2 days of snap budget.  Then Friday, I took the squash with me to my dad’s house and tried to cook it the rest of the way. It was okay. Not great. I left the leftovers with my dad. I don’t care for left over lamb.

Breakfasts this week remained pretty normal. The weekdays were some variation of the recipes below.

image10

Oh, eating breakfast amongst the groceries that still need to be put away.

No sugar Oatmeal and sausage: Bring water, cinnamon, and raisins to boil, add a bit of muesli and old fashioned oats. Turn off stove, mix in a bit of vanilla at that point and let sit while the sausage finishes cooking. Top with plain yogurt.

image6Egg and Gouda English muffins: Toast English muffins with Gouda on them, put on a little mayo, salt and pepper, add scrambled egg and eat with a side of sautéed zucchini. So good!

Sausage and English muffins with cream cheese and jelly with apple slices on the side.

image2Saturday morning was way better. I got to use the challah bread for French toast. I needed to use the left over sausage from this week’s breakfasts, and I had bacon in the fridge as well. So we had French toast, made with cinnamon nutmeg, clove, and vanilla in the egg batter. We topped it with frozen blueberries and the last banana from our Winco trip, topped with a tiny bit of maple syrup and plain yogurt. Today, I didn’t feel like cooking so Liam had cereal, from Food for Lane county and I had coffee and toast.

 

image8

The cheddar cheese went over well, and was gone after two afterschool snacks, and a packed school snacks. All in all I think it made three sandwiches, and two packed school snacks.

image9

I found the back of the Late July crackers to be an amusing read at the breakfast table. Despite such a big box, those lasted for about 2 snacks, one the night he got them, then one after school.

image5Snacks this week were also pretty normal, other than the ingredients were of higher quality than usual and therefore, it was a bit more frustrating when Liam wasted them.  I also gave him the possibly local bell pepper. He didn’t like it. It tasted funny apparently and wasted a bunch of it at school. I packed him leftover oatmeal from breakfasts. Sliced carrots, and golden delicious apples. I have to cut most everything so he can eat things with his braces.

image1Lunches happened for Liam at school mostly and more often than not I ended up skipping. Though I did have a meeting over lunch and there was food there this week, so I ate that. I did end up eating a banana for snack, but as per usual, I was mostly way hungry come dinner time. Today as we prepped the apples and pears my dad gave us from food for lane county for sauce, I stuffed a few pears with feta, chopped almonds, cranberries, and dried figs and baked them.  Liam stuffed his with cream cheese and cranberries.  This was pretty darn tasty!

Dinners, other than the traumatizing squash were pretty tasty. There was the stew mentioned, then Wednesday after a very long day there was chicken meat balls and potatoes that a friend made us. It was glorious to be able to just pop that in the oven. It amazes me even with that, I still ended up spending a lot of time in the kitchen this week. I cannot recall the specifics of the other meals. I am using the tomatillos tonight in guacamole and as a salsa on top of the enchiladas I pulled from the freezer. I actually have to end this post now, as I need to go cook dinner. My conclusion will follow shortly.

Eating locally on SNAP: The Intersection of Access, Leisure, and Labor (Update 1)

Well, it is day one and many of my original rules are already tossed by the wayside.  I am allowing myself coffee, I think my son likes me more with coffee.  I am allowing myself to accept food from friends.  and I am allowing myself to eat out if I am by myself using that time to work at a coffee shop.  This term is insane and breaking those rules is helping me navigate it.  I would also like to apologize in advance as this will be my longest post, but I promise pictures to keep you interested.

Like I mentioned in my introduction post, in approaching this blog project I am working with the following general assumption: the likelihood that those of us on SNAP will be on other assistance programs ranging from WIC, State health insurance, and housing assistance etc. is very high. I bring this up again here because just as food cannot be abstracted from daily life, the interlocking demands that these programs place on an individual cannot be separated from each other. To illustrate this I decided to start this post out with a few highlights of my life navigating some of these interlocking demands. For context, the document I was working from when preparing this blog post is saved on my computer as “degradation rituals.”  I find the title fitting.  The following snapshots are either background situations and/or relatively current events. While not all of them visibly connect to food, though some do, in my experience these snapshots all fundamentally shape my food choices in a variety of ways.

Snapshot on the last time I went to farmers market.

I will start with this one as it is directly related to food. This 11147575_1116891708327083_1891565276898808347_owas probably four years ago, maybe five. My son has always been very high energy and super challenging behavior wise, and I have always been learning how best to solo parent him as I go. This trip to market was well before his formal diagnoses of ADHD and anxiety. I had a WIC voucher that was expiring that day that was specific for the farmers market rather than the produce section in the grocery store. They give a certain number out each summer and I think it was for 30 dollars. This was my last chance to spend this voucher and we needed food. Things started out okay, but once I started to try to pick out produce, my son started running off into the crowds. When he wasn’t running off, he was picking up and handling all the produce. I was ungracefully juggling the items we wanted to buy, and unlike other shoppers, I didn’t have a fancy 60 dollar wicker basket imported from Central America. I also had to be very specific to keep within the limits of the voucher as I didn’t have cash and couldn’t go over the limit. I was also trying (unsuccessfully) to hold onto my son. People passed us 10960126_1036568229692765_7897992798998628072_otrying to get to their own produce. I received plenty impatient sighs and middle class side-eyes as I struggled with the list, the produce, and the unruly child. Not one person offered to help, not even the people working in the stands.  They all seemed busy catching up with regular customers. Embarrassed and near tears I put down all the produce, picked up my son and left the market. When I reached the elevator in the parking garage, the tears came and as I was venting about not having food, and not being able to use the voucher because of my son’s behavior a woman got on the elevator and decided that it was entirely appropriate to comment on my poor parenting choices rather than even consider ways she could help. That was the last time I went to market. I no longer considered the space welcoming to people in my situation as a broke and overwhelmed single mom.  How can this particular moment be captured in the snap challenge?

 

Snapshot on how to spend a quarter

coins-521245_640Higher education has been for me, as it is for many others, a path out of poverty. My decision to attend graduate school was primarily to increase my son’s life chances. While SNAP and other Federal assistance programs put forth a personal success and independence rhetoric, in my experience, they are ultimately not supportive of higher education beyond the undergraduate level. Once I transitioned to the graduate program, my food benefits decreased dramatically. Prior to this current school year, I was under contract as a GTF and while my stipend was certainly far less than a living wage for a household of two, I was receiving 16.00 dollars per month. That is about .50 cents a day, or a quarter per person in a 30 day month. At one point, when 90% of my annual 11K stipend went to childcare costs, I think I was receiving about $230 per month, which is a little over 8 dollars a day, or $4.00 per person across a 30 day month. But remember, 90% of my earned income was going to childcare.

 

Luckily during this time, I was receiving child-support, albeit less than the court ordered amount and the majority of the child-support went to paying off the 30,000 dollar debt I ended up with in my divorce. Furthermore, if we are paying attention to time, countless hours which cannot be detailed here, along hundreds of dollars in legal fees went into fighting the state and my son’s father to make that happen. They wanted to consider my 900.00 a month childcare expenses to be zero as my GTF was part time employment and my course work childcare needs were not considered work related. So in my situation, what exactly was SNAP supplementing? Student loans which at this point are up to about 100k. With this in mind, I am curious if there is a snap challenge that asks people to plan their food money around a quarter a day?

Snapshot on Losing time

In July of this year, I had reported that my GTF contract ended and my income had dropped. Because it was summer term I was not enrolled in graduate school. Therefore, I was told to come in and participate in what they call an OFFSET program, where a person’s eligibility of snap benefits is dependent on their job search efforts. This is similar to the one for TANF benefits, though not as intensive. I couldn’t make the date for the orientation and had to try to reschedule. In the meantime, my food stamps remained at the prior amount from when I was receiving my GTF stipend.  I had to call several times to get the orientation scheduled which finally happened in late August. After spending an hour or two in the SNAP office with my son, I was then required to meet a certain number of “job contacts” in the month for two months in a row. They back dated it to the original orientation date, so I had two weeks to complete the first month’s contact requirements, and the last month’s requirements would have went well into the beginning of my term.

IMG_6256Even though I was going back to school in three weeks and students with children are not required to do the Offset program, I was limited by the boxes they have to routinely check. My situation couldn’t and wouldn’t be viewed as a whole. I was forced to spend 2 months looking for a job and whatever job I found, I was obligated to keep or I would risk losing my food benefits. This ignores the fact that any regular job I found would not accommodate my upcoming schedule and it seems that I would have been forced to have them fire me, because quitting would have been in violation of the program requirements.  I then spent the next few weeks of my summer writing resumes, making job contacts, and wasting time to jump through their hoops. My food stamps increased to about 290 per month, which is about 4.80 per person per day, but I wasn’t actually aware of this increase as they are only required to notify you of decreases, and I thought my application was still in limbo. Luckily the State of Oregon carries over snap dollars to the next month, some states do not. During this time, I also obtained flexible employment on campus, so I didn’t need to spend a second month making their required contacts. However, the same day I submitted my job contact log and reported obtaining employment, my annual recertification packet was also sent to me to fill out and return.

image4Besides the annual recertification, there are interim reports and required change reports to maintain SNAP eligibility; a recipient can, and does spend, quite a bit of time filling out paperwork, collecting supporting documents, and turning them in. In addition to staying on top of the paper work for food stamps, I am also on Section 8 housing and I have to fill out recertification paper work for them, submit supporting documents and bank statements annually, and reporting any changes in income within 14 days of their occurrence. I am also required to meet for at least an hour with my case worker on a regular basis, which has been at least once per term, if not more. I am also required to have a worker come out and inspect my home once a year. I have to either arrange for another adult to be there or I have to take time to be there and the window for arrival is usually anywhere between 8am and 1pm. This can get complicated as I usually have to drop my son off at school at 8:25. Then there is paper work required for the state health insurance and the time it takes for that which is very similar, if not more redundant than the other paperwork I have described. While we are on the topic of state insurance, I recently spent three hours just trying to get a prescription filled, about an hour of which was sitting on hold with OHP to ask why they denied my prescription, the rest was driving back and forth and waiting in the pharmacy that wanted to charge me 150.00 for my prescription. How often does it take three hours to fill a prescription with a regular insurance company? In contrast, when I had the GTF insurance, I never had a problem filling prescriptions and I rarely spent more than 10 minutes on hold.

FullSizeRender_1So with piles of forms, all coming at different times year I can find myself filling out and submitting paper at least every two or three months. It truly feels like I am constantly filling out paperwork and none of these programs take into consideration that they have my all of my information on file. I find this worth repeating. These organizations all have my information on file! They also have the means to look up all the information I provide to them before I provide it. Yet I am required to fill out new paperwork every time, down to our social security numbers and address. I would think housing authority knows my address. I find that my handwriting is at its worst on state applications, I consider this is my own private resistance to the endless hoops they keep me jumping through.

I have touched on this a bit above, but many times jumping through these hoops requires me to lose time at work. A recent example comes from the shift in my employment from being a GTF to being a student worker. I had questions about my paper work in relationship to this change. I had read on the documents that I was not eligible for foodstamps if I was a full time student who was not also working 20 hours a week. It turns out as a parent, I am exempt from this requirement, but I was confused about this at the time and called my case worker to ask about the details of my particular situation so that I could fill out the recertification paperwork correctly. A few days later, I received a call back from a different person saying that my questions were too general to warrant a call back from my actual case worker and that I needed to come into a drop in appointment to ask my questions.

In order to go into the SNAP office, I ended up having to take two hours off of work.  (yes, I bolded and italicized  this sentence on purpose) On a side note, this paticular snap office is located in the building the old Waremart grocery store used to be. It was very much like winco, but even more like a warehouse, hence the name.  It was where all the snap recipients shopped because the cheap food was there in large quantities. I spent a bit of time in this building as a child.  I also spent time pushing carts of food home from it. Well, it closed down when I was about 10 or so and they opened the SNAP office there shortly afterwards.  I find this ironic.

When I arrived at the office, they wouldn’t answer my questions without filling out the paperwork so I sat down with the forms and brought them back completed to the front desk. I stood in line and waited both times. Once information was entered into the computer each relevant page was stamped, (which was most of the pages),  they told me a case worker could meet with me in a half hour for the required interview, or I could come back another day. I chose to wait. I was prepared with reading for this class , ironically on claimsmaking around food insecurity and hunger.  I am lucky enough to be able to bring work with me. I am not sure how many other people on snap have this type of work, so for many, they cannot multitask like I was able to. Once it was time for my interview, the case worker led me through a maze of grey cubicles and then looking between my paper work on the desk and her computer in front of her she proceeded to verbally ask me each question that I had already filled out, and put the answer in the computer. Then she gave me more paperwork to have my employers fill out and return. It is important to note that I have never once had the same case worker twice. By the time I reapply or report a change, my file is on to a new caseworker.

image1So at this point I hope you are wondering where a single mother who is in graduate school full time, working three separate part time jobs, and parenting a high needs child 100% solo finds the time to go through these degradation rituals? Though  I can’t actually answer that, because I don’t know. More importantly though, we need to ask what happens to the people who just get tired of the endless paperwork and demoralization? Actually, I know what happens to some of them because I can remember being 15 or 16 years old and following my mom out of the SNAP office just after welfare reform. She left in the middle of an offset orientation. Needless to say, we didn’t get our food stamps renewed. As someone who has lived this, how any of it can be captured in a week long or even month long SNAP challenge is beyond me. Furthermore, the absence of any pedagogical effort to capture even some of this in undergraduate classes makes the snap challenge feel like a glorified, but educational, version of poverty tourism.

But what about food?!

So now that we have gotten the paperwork out of the way, let us talk briefly about the actual food, that is what the snap challenge is about right?  While today was the official day I started tracking, I actually attempted to go to the grocery store last night. I had given up on being able to find the time to get to place with good local options. When I started thinking about this project, I had intended to get all of my bread items at the 100 mile bakery in Springfield, my meat at Longs, and my produce at the Corner Market farm stand off of River Road as it is by my house. Well time to do all of this never magically materialized in my life; so in the end, being out of most everything on a Sunday night and needing at least the next day’s breakfast and snacks for the boy, I drove to Winco only to get almost there and realize I forgot my EBT card. So we drove home. Yesterday was not a good day.  As it was a school night, I didn’t have time to drive all the way back out to WinCo before needing to get the kid in bed, so I opted for the Red Barn. to at least get a few things. While there I impromptu decided that this would be a good chance to see what I could find that was local. While good for the project this was ultimately bad for my pocket book. Keeping in mind, I didn’t prepare a menu plan ahead of time, so I tried to only get things that were on my grocery list as staples I usually use.

Overall I spent about $99.00 dollars at red barn.  I got four local golden delicious apples these should last for four days as snacks for my son and/or ingredients in meals for both of us. I purchased a dozen local eggs and gallon of organic valley milk which will last the week and more with my son drinking it and me using it to cook with. I got a small bag of local whole wheat flour; I don’t know why I bought this. I didn’t have time to come up with a meal plan and it was there and local, so I did. I also got a few carrots, four small local beets which are a staple in our kitchen, along with a large head of purple cabbage, another staple. I use these in an amazing slaw that my son loves (recipe to follow in another post as this post is already entirely too long).  I purchased a small bag of local tomatillos and a celery root, again no meal plan really, but they were local. I picked up two tiny blocks of organic, but not local, cheese, one Gouda and one white cheddar. When I say tiny blocks, I mean tiny, almost pointless in my family tiny—we go through a lot of cheese, but keeping with the spirit of this project, I purchased the miniscule cheeses and a small bag of garnet yams. The yams will probably make one meal if I cook them as a side, possibly two if I mix them as an ingredient. The cheeses, at most might make it through a few breakfasts, maybe a lunch and an afterschool snack or two.

Funny thing is the yams and a few other local items like the tomatoes we bought where in a mixed bin marked “some local,” leaving me to intuit which ones looked local and which ones were imposters. I also got one bell pepper that was marked local, though when I got it home I saw a sticker on it that suggests it is not local. My son can go through one bellpepper as part of one snack. I got a small organic squash which will end up as part of one or two meals. I also got a loaf of bread, a bag of bagels, and some Challah bread, not obviously local ingredients, but from a local small business. The bread products should last a week. My kid spent his $2 dollars of pocket money on a vitamin C tablet and a $4.00 dollar box of “natural” crackers. I picked up the difference for the crackers on my EBT. I cannot buy vitamins on EBT. I also purchased a small thing of Sweet Creek farms jelly and one of their enchilada sauces. I have enchiladas that I made before the term started stashed in the freezer and needed sauce so I can pull a few out for dinner sometime this week. As far as the jelly and sauce, source of ingredients was not apparent to me, but the company is near the coast. Oh I also got peanut butter.

So all of this food, except for the milk fit loosely into two bags. That is near $100.00 dollars for two bags of mostly local groceries. My food budget for the week was about $65 dollars. I do not expect much of this food, besides the flour, jelly, and peanut butter to last far into next week and without drawing on food in my cupboards and freezer, on their own, I don’t expect these items to make full breakfasts, lunches, and dinners for the week. Checking out with all these groceries was hard as the counter was small, my son was super chatty and less than helpful (imagine that), and I was bagging my own groceries with one of the bags on the floor even as there was not room for it on the counter. There was a line behind me, and it felt a little reminiscent of my traumatizing trip to market I described earlier. Leaving the store I remembered why I usually only go to the Red Barn for tiny trips.

That was last night. Today, I went to WinCo to get other things I needed really badly, like non-food items that red barn doesn’t carry at anywhere reasonable prices. Besides non-food items, I needed more food. With a kid, three jobs, grad school and all that paperwork, I don’t have time for weekly shopping trips. When I put food in my cupboard, I need it to last. Typically I will do really big shopping trips during the breaks between terms (using both by ebt and my debit card), prepare a bunch of food for my freezer during the break and then do smaller monthly or biweekly trips as staples run low during the term. This is the only way week 5 and on is anywhere near bearable, and even that isn’t guaranteed.

So anyways this afternoon, I got the boy from school, at 2:45. On the way home, we stopped at Longs meat market to order our turkey for thanksgiving and to pick up 9 dollars worth of sausage for the next two weeks’ school day breakfasts. We arrived home at about 3:30 where I prepared him (not me) an after school snack of Pb&J on the fancy redbarn bread. After he ate and I got my list together we left for WinCo at about 4:20. For the sanity of everyone I will not list what I bought. But for comparison’s sake I brought home 5 bags very full with groceries spending about 156.00. For $57.00 dollars more than what I spent at the red barn, I got more than twice as much food, some of which will probable last 3 or 4 times as long.

We got home from the store at a little after 6pm and immediately started putting the cold groceries away, leaving the other bags piled on the table for later. If you remember, I didn’t eat snack, nor did I eat very well at work and class today, and at breakfast I had the much smaller portions, so by this time I was what my son and I call “shaky hungry.” I was flushed and hot and unfocused. Unlike the politicians who take the snap challenge, I am used to it. Earlier, my friend had brought us some food he had made. I was truly grateful for this as I didn’t have to think about what to cook. We had left overs in the fridge to from the night before so I put all of that in the oven and while that was cooking we cleaned up as much as we could in the kitchen. I was also very lucky as my son was being super helpful so it was low stress and his teacher forgot to give out the homework today so he didn’t have to work on that, which was a relief as I was busy and the table was still full of groceries. Eating amongst the bags of groceries at the table was pretty cramped but mostly uneventful. We ate off paper plates, as the kitchen was still not clean fully.  I finished eating before my son did and while he finished, I worked to get the rest of the groceries put away. At 7:15 my son finished eating and I sat down to work on this blog post, the kitchen is still not clean. From the point I picked him up from school, to the point I sat down in total is 4.5 hours doing food related things. This does not count the half hour I spent this morning cooking his breakfast and packing his snack. Given not every day includes a trip to the store, particularly one in which I am doing such a close inspection of the prices to compare them to the options at the Red Barn.  However, the daily time I spend on food related things is not insubstantial. Today I clocked 5 hours of food activity.

Over the next few days I will track all my food related activities.  During the next post I will talk more about time and I will detail more about  my experience purchasing all the local food and how it relates to fair labor practices, but for tonight this post is more than long enough, and as it is, I still have to do some version of editing this post and find those pictures I promised.

Goodnight!

AfterMath SNAP + Match +local

I realized I misrepresented my last entry that says Day 4. This was after the fifth day, because I had added an additional SNAP only day at $4.40.

Since the completion of the challenge, I have gone back to the market and also the supermarket and found the farmers market a more pleasant experience. I found I was one of the people standing on the sidewalk in the middle of the bustle, talking to a volunteer I worked with during the summer. I went back and spoke to Jeff, the oatmeal guy, to share my experience of the challenge and to thank him for the way the oatmeal kept me going.  I struck up a conversation with a new vendor, and it felt like a genuine interaction that is sustainable into the future. I plan to ask him if I can visit his farm some time. Other vendors I bought from recognized me. I have become part of the market community.

Most importantly, I conclude that despite what everyone seems to believe, it is very possible to eat well at the market on a severely limited budget. When I went back, I only spent approximately the same amount as I did for the entire 5 day challenge, but I am eating VERY well with the addition of some fermented vegetables and greens. I am convinced buying at the market is a healthier way to eat, it does support local farmers and food producers, and it is reducing my dependence on manufactured and processed supermarket food, which tends to be more expensive. I am trying to buy mostly locally produced foods at the supermarket as well (ex. Surata tempeh and tofu). Overall, I believe I will spend less money on food using this methodology. Since I have been tracking monthly food expenses for the past several years, this will be easy to determine within one full month.

What is unknown is the status of labor in connection to the local food purchases I am making. It appears that some of the smaller scale vendors might be the primary laborers on their farms. Speaking to them over time might reveal if they hire additional seasonal or permanent labor, and where that labor originates. I would like to do some farm tours to get a sense of the labor issues.

What is wrong with the federal SNAP program

I call this section AfterMath, as it is not just about my own SNAP + Match + local challenge calculations, but a disturbing realization that presented itself during the course of the challenge. We are using the average $4.40 per day per person figure for our challenges. I went to the Federal SNAP website to understand more about the program and how SNAP benefits are determined. http://www.fns.usda.gov/snap/eligibility#Income

It says:

“The amount of benefits the household gets is called an allotment. The net monthly income of the household is multiplied by .3, and the result is subtracted from the maximum allotment for the household size to find the household’s allotment. This is because SNAP households are expected to spend about 30 percent of their resources on food”.

The maximum allotment for 1 person is $194 per month.

Using their not so handy calculation guidelines, I calculated my allotment based on a gross earned income of $1,000.

First I would deduct a standard 20% to determine net income = $800, then deduct a standard $155 for a family size of 1-3 = $645.

If my shelter costs are more than half of my income, (let’s say I am renting a room at a friend’s house for $350 a month), then I would deduct the difference from this adjusted amount or $645/2 = $322.50 (for 50% of net income). $350- $322.50 = $27.50 excess shelter cost.

$645- $27.50 = $617.50 x .3 = $185 adjusted net income.

$194 max allotment – $185.25 = $8.75 allotment benefits per month.

(If someone wishes to check my math, I would appreciate it, as this is not my forte).

Now I understand why when I applied a few years ago as a student on a limited budget and after being put on hold for about 10 minutes while the woman crunched numbers, I was offered $16 per month. I told the woman to withdraw my electronic application and went to the local food bank instead.

Fancy math is being used to systematically discriminate against our society’s most needy individuals. The fact that the allotment is tied to income is terrible, as it means that those who need the most assistance receive the least amount. People with less income are no less hunger that people who earn or receive more income. Poorer people are being treated as if they were less than one person!!!! All people need a minimum number of calories per day to maintain normal biological functions. Those engaged in more strenuous physical labor require additional calories and nutrition to replace greater caloric expenditures.

If we are really going to talk about food justice and food being a human right, then each person in need of food assistance should receive a set amount per day that is a realistic amount to purchase food for a day in a variety of environments (supermarket, farmers market, online, etc.) and not some fraction of that amount.

Food workers are disproportionally paid the least amount of money for their labor. Yet only a small percentage of these workers receive food assistance in the form of SNAP benefits.

Perhaps my own self-imposed $2.20 per day limit during the first 4 days of the challenge begins to approximate the higher end of the eating budget of a farmworker, but their diet would necessarily involve other food choices based on availability and cultural choices.

My simple analysis of the inhumane and discriminatory practices of the federal SNAP program points to the need for advocacy work to change the benefit guidelines policies. In my mind, I see a campaign poster that shows a line of photos of a whole person and others that are shown as partial people with percentage number underneath, with a clear message that all people are equally hungry, not half hungry or a quarter hungry. The poster would show how much each person receives per day.

Below is my chart of meal descriptions and photos from the challenge.

[embeddoc url=”https://blogs.uoregon.edu/envs607f12/files/2015/10/AfterMath-SNAP-local-11ljk0o.docx” download=”all” viewer=”microsoft”]

Day 4: SNAP + Match + local challenge

Day 4

I have decided to end my SNAP + Match + local challenge as of last night, but will do a one day SNAP challenge. I can’t eat anymore oatmeal or eggs for a while, because it creates too much mucous in my body. What is left is 1 full pound of oatmeal, 3 eggs, less than 1/4 cup of butter and a bowl of steamed napa cabbage, which at this point doesn’t appeal to me.

Today, I will go to the Market of Choice for the first time in almost 2 weeks. Already, when I think about it in relationship to our readings, I realize that for me, most supermarkets feel like a food museum, because out of thousands of items, there are so few items I am interested in buying. When I shop, I first go to the fresh food section and see what organic vegetables are on sale. I buy a brassica family vegetable, which can be kale or broccoli or cabbage, or maybe zucchini. Although I enjoy salad, I rarely buy lettuce, because I won’t eat it fast enough, and it will go to waste. I prefer to blend up some organic celery, carrots, kale, or other greens, an apple and some blueberries with a protein mix and liquefy it in the blender. I tried to buy bulk organic lettuce, but you have to pick through it so much and choose the right day when it is put out fresh. After that I pick up specific foods in other sections and in 10-15 minutes, I am out of the store with a backpack worth of groceries. I never use a shopping cart; only what I can carry in a handbasket.

Too much abundance can be damaging in some same and some different ways than grocery deserts. Even Trader Joe’s is much too big a store for me, as I only buy foods from certain sections. When it comes down to it, shopping in a supermarket is overwhelming, because there are too many choices. It is also a lonely experience; we see people everywhere doing the same activity, but they are mostly strangers we are trying to avoid. It is an illusion of a social experience. People who don’t have social connections, often use shopping as a way to get their people fix, by people-watching or simply shopping for anything.  I think it is something we have grown accustomed to, but is not healthy. This is a manipulated activation of the “shopping” “acquiring” primitive part of our over marketing to modern brains. As we know, this can have negative repercussions for both health and finances. We usually buy more than we wrote down on our list at home. We impulse buy, going through a quick rationalization process or else thoughtlessly abandon ourselves to the moment.

When I go to a U-Pick blueberry farm, I notice the shift in consciousness that occurs during the experience. Usually it is a group experience, I invite friends or family and we talk amidst the rows, our fingers searching for the best, easiest to reach fruit. I believe it activates that same primitive part of our brain associated with similar ancient experiences of gathering that occurred as part of extended family and tribal life, firmly imbedded in our genetics. Our gatherer mind gets switched on. We think different thoughts and have conversations about things we had not considered before. Best of all, it creates a shared memory we refer to when we make blueberry pancakes during the winter.

The farmers market is an intermediary experience between gathering and supermarket shopping. We are still looking for the best prices and the best quality food, but the social interaction is not quite as impersonal as in a supermarket. We must talk to a person to get our food, and this person is connected to particular food and its origin. In a crowded market like the Saturday market, the physicality of the social jostling and negotiating of space can be an intense experience. We can hide in the crowd. The Tuesday market puts you on the spot with each interaction. You might feel obliged to make small talk since you and the vendor are in proximity without distractions.

There are other sensorial benefits in the market; the aroma of fresh produce is tantalizing and can’t be reproduced in a supermarket environment. It is the smell of the earth, the signature smell of each plant species boldly presents itself. Smell is an underrated sense in our modern world, but I feel attuned to it. Cats won’t eat unless they can smell their food, which is why they need room temperature food. In humans, the smell of food cooking stimulates our salivary glands and prepares our digestive systems, thus family and group meals of slower cooked food, as opposed to snacking, has additional health benefits beyond the social. We digest our food better, and tend to eat slower in the presence of others.

The sights at the market are remarkable. Vendors go to great lengths to merchandize their produce in visually enticing ways. Taking their cue from retail, they place foods in aesthetically appealing arrangements, and use a variety of pricing solutions. It reflects individual creativity rather than corporate. The brilliant colors combine to create a riotous food collage that imprints on the memory. I have taken dozens and dozens of market food photos simply because the produce is so beautiful. The entire market experience comes alive when you look at even one of these photos.

It can take more time to get through the market too, which is also what makes it a healthier social experience than a supermarket. At least at first, it is not a personal experience, but by buying from specific vendors, you establish rapport over time. Yes, this does also happen with supermarket cashiers, but it is not the same thing. The other phenomena I witness social; people see friends and neighbors, and they recognize others from different spheres of life.  They stop and spontaneously chat in the middle of the bustle, like ants touching antennae.  Music is a permanent fixture of the Saturday market gestalt too. Listening and watching musicians perform classical and blues at 9 in the morning is good for the soul, and supports local talent that might struggle to find the right venue.

It is time to go to Market of Choice now, where I will try to get a full day worth of food for $4.40. I have my doubts that it can be done, but I will try. It probably won’t be local. I am hungry and plan to be the first customer at the store.

After the store: I didn’t know what to buy. Much of the produce looked visibly wilted and unappealing. I found a small head of conventional broccoli, as the organic broccoli heads were huge and would have put me over budget, even though the price per pound was the same. I bought ramen noodles to keep my full, and potatoes just in case, but I never needed them, since the soup I made was so filling.  I bought string cheese, but it just produced more mucous. Nothing local or organic. I had 33 cents left over.

At the end of the day, I returned to the store to buy new food, and had a similar shopping experience; I didn’t know what to buy. I noticed the prices on prepared food are so much higher than buying raw ingredients at the Eugene market. Since I did live on $2.20 per day, I know I can easily live on $4.40 per day and eat better. I am quick at preparing nutritious meals. Maybe the supermarket is no longer my main shopping venue. Perhaps my healthy experience of farmers market eating only has been the transition I needed to wean me off most supermarket shopping. I can hardly wait until Saturday to buy some more fresh market vegetables and fruits. It’s been a positive experience with good outcomes.

 

Day 3: SNAP + Match + local challenge

Day 3

Although this diet is very restricted, I do not feel I am suffering or am deprived in any way. I feel reasonably full, because I am eating 4 small meals a day and trying not to eat too fast. Water helps too. It turns out the cream for the butter could come from Washington, Oregon, Northern California or Idaho, so local on this item was an unrealistic idea. A creamery within a 100 miles doth not local cream or butter guarantee. Larsen’s is near Portland at 109 miles away.

Today I did tell myself I should make something more interesting, so instead of the usual fried eggs, I made an onion, cabbage and egg omelet, which turned out great and kept me fed as part of other meals all day. I had to cut the onion portion smaller and my squash pieces smaller so the food will last through Wednesday.

My choices of both oatmeal and eggs could not have been worse as far as timing goes, because I must have gotten a cold from all the students on campus, and my nose has been running. Since I only get a cold about once every 5 years, this is kind of a drag. I don’t even usually eat oatmeal anymore, partially because it tends to be mucous producing, and I am sensitive to all carbs that way in general. I am somewhat sensitive to both wheat and dairy, so only eat those items in moderation (1-2 times per week max).  I am feeling better though.

There was an unexpected surprise today in the form of the seeds inside the squash. Originally, I was thinking that I was losing food because of the space in the middle, but when I opened the lower half of the butternut, the seeds presented a new food choice. It only took me 10 minutes to clean up the seeds and put them on a baking tray in the oven, something I would not normally bother doing. 10 more minutes later and I had a new snack food that lasted me all day.

Some thought from day 1 I meant to write. It isn’t just about food, we also need water to cook with, and ours comes from the McKenzie River, which requires infrastructure, maintenance and testing that we often take for granted. Someday I will finish the rough draft of a short story I started writing called, “The Village Well” about my experiences with water and community in Mexico.

Then there are our pots and pans and utensils, plates and bowls and gadgets they are produced in factories faraway by underpaid labor. As I started thinking about this, I realized how large a proportion of our homes and possession relate in some way to food, and that also includes our bathrooms and garbage. These are just some things upon which to reflect. I have been using the same two cast iron pans since I was 19 for most of my daily cooking. I have a couple of pieces of my mom’s original stainless steel Faberware set, and a client gave me the gift of a fancy rice cooker one Christmas, which is so useful for steaming and slow cooking, as well as for rice.

I question our built environment a lot. How it tends to socially and psychologically isolate us even though we are social beings by nature. Eating alone instead of with other people can be lonely and it is really such an easy issue to resolve through co-housing for example. To me, this is all related to Food Studies too. It is about making conscious decisions about everything we do in order improve and protect our well being and that of the earth.

I didn’t know I had so much will power to ignore other foods in my environment and out in the world.

 

Day 1 SNAP + Match + local challenge

Day 1: October 10th

I went to the market on Tuesday to get tokens and buy some of my food items in preparation for todays’ start date. This was part of my strategy to save money. I had heard the Tuesday market often had better prices than Saturday, even though they are some of the same vendors. I am not sure if this is true or not, but I think it is worth knowing. This would mean that since the Saturday market includes more tourists and people who can’t take off work to attend the Tuesday market, they pay a premium.

First I scouted around to compare prices and found some big organic onions at a $1 each, and napa cabbage at the same stand for only $1.00 per lb., which was less expensive than regular cabbage. I also found a good sized butternut squash for $1.00 per lb. which was a lot less than some of the stands. Originally, I thought I might use potatoes as my main carbohydrate, but when I had checked the prices last week, that did not seem like a realistic choice at $2.49 or more per lb. Although I knew I would have to wait until Saturday to buy the oatmeal from Jeff, I was hopeful to buy eggs from Blissfully Produced out of Junction City, because they are only $5 a dozen. Other Saturday vendors charge more. Unfortunately the egg vendor was not there. I spent $6.00 on Tuesday

Today, I went to the Saturday market after eating my first breakfast with the onions and cabbage I had bought on Tuesday. I didn’t want to be hungry when I arrived at the market. When I asked the egg vendor, how much she wanted for the eggs, my jaw nearly dropped: $8 per dozen!  In my mind, I considered $6 a price higher than I was willing to pay. Normally I buy Wilcox or another at least regional brand and try not to pay more than $4 by buying them when they are on sale. I don’t usually eat that many eggs, so a box usually lasts me 2-3 weeks.

Since I knew I could not afford $8, I first asked if I could buy a half dozen, even though I knew that would not be enough eggs for the challenge. When I explained my situation with the challenge, she seemed willing to accommodate such a request, even though I had not brought my own box. Then I asked her if she knew of any other egg vendors at the market and she pointed across the way to a meat vendor. He had eggs at $6 a dozen, so that was the best I could do. His eggs came in plastic packaging, which I was upset about, but I couldn’t be fussy.

I went to buy oats from Jeff, and talked to him about my food challenge, and he seemed interested in knowing what I had chosen. I told him oats was the most important part of my plan. I am not sure, but I think he lowered the price by a $1, because I thought I first heard him say $6 for 2 lbs., which would have been over my budget, but then after we talked and I asked how much I owed him, he said $5.

That’s it: I could only buy those two items and go home. This means no fruit, and I will have break my rule, and go over budget to include ¼ lb stick of Mother’s Choice butter I had bought previously, which has a value of $1.37. I don’t usually use much butter, but this was the only fat I could think of that would be local or regional. I contacted the Larsen Creamery to find out where their cream comes from.

The tea I am drinking during the challenge is a half box of Trader Joe’s organic Fair Trade Rooibos and Honeybush I found in the give-away pile in the laundry room in my building. It is the opposite of local, coming from South Africa, but at least it is organic and Fair Trade.

In preparation for this food adventure and because I already trying to do this anyway, I weaned myself off of chocolate, which has been one of my indulgences since I returned to being a student 5 years ago. Before that, I was never interested in it. It represents a comfort and a reward.

Even on day 1, I can feel my attitude towards food shifting away from it being pleasurable, to just a way to maintain health and nutrition as it used to be for me for most of my life. In 2006, I began taking a greater interest in eating more thoughtfully prepared and presented meals. This came about as a convergence of three elements: 1. my income increased and I didn’t have to think so much about how much I was spending on food, 2. A male friend from Mexico came and stayed with me for 3 months, and I felt culturally obligated to cook for him every day, and 3. I had a care client who enjoyed watching cooking show several times a week, so even though I had not watched television for years, I did with her (this was interesting, because she was recently blind, but still enjoyed cooking). I was inspired by learning new cooking techniques. I read the book Heat by Bill Buford, and another chef book I can’t recall. I was becoming a foody, even though I was far more interested in gardening. My main interest since then has been complex flavors using a variety of herbs and spices, nothing fancy though.

Back to the present: I am surprised by how quickly I am able to drop my attachment to food and my habit of snacking, usually making good choices, and returning to a more utilitarian food mind set. I have never been the type of cook who makes a list and shops with a specific meal in mind. I am more of a spontaneous cook who feels creatively challenged to use what I have to prepare something delicious and nutritious. Now that I have mostly lived alone for 5 years, it has been interesting to observe how much or how little effort I am willing to spend on cooking for one person. I much prefer to feed at least several people, and then I am very inspired (I raised a family of 4 children and often there were housemates too).

The eggs have an unusual, almost creamy texture. Perhaps since they come from a meat farm, the chickens are being fed some animal parts. I will ask the farmer about this.

SNAP + Match + local Food Rules

SNAP  + Match + local Food Rules

I am still shocked at how little money people receive through food stamp programs.  I started shopping at the market this summer, since I was volunteering there.  So I have decided to challenge myself to see if I can successfully combine the SNAP and local food challenges by purchasing most food items at the farmers market. I am creating this specific challenge because it seems that almost everyone believes that farmers markets are too expensive for people who have a limited food budget. The SNAP Match is the only way I can theoretically add money to the $2.40 x 5 days = $12 amount I will have.  I found out that the Eugene farmers market does not have SNAP Match yet, but the Springfield Sprout market does. This amounts to a maximum additional  $5 for $10 worth of tokens purchased.  This means I will have a total of $17 to spend. I plan to fudge this aspect of my challenge as I will be shopping at the Eugene market and not the Sprout market. I am “pretending” that Eugene already has SNAP Match, which means I have created a hypothetical, but still realistic purchasing scenario.

I plan to start on Saturday October 10th, as I want to take advantage of lower prices at the peak of the harvest season. I decided to do the challenge for only 5 days rather than 7, as I have a lot going on next week, and a paper to present on Friday the 16th.

I have made a list of the foods I think will fit within my budget and together provide balanced nutrition. These are eggs for protein, oatmeal for carbs and to keep me full, onions for flavor, a winter squash for vitamins and good taste, cabbage because it has a lot of calcium and is versatile.  I hope I can afford some apples as my fruit. I will use butter as my fat for cooking, but I am not sure if I can buy this at the farmers market.

“Rules”

  1. It’s OK to buy food ahead of time in order to prepare.
  2. It’s OK to drink hot herbal tea that I already have on hand (this is going to be my only “pleasure”).
  3. It’s OK to use a few specific condiments, which will be: salt, cayenne pepper, oregano and cinnamon.
  4. I will keep track of how long it takes to walk to the market, shop and return home.
  5. I will take a picture of the tokens and money I will spend.
  6. I will take pictures of the food I purchase and use.
  7. I will record how much time it takes to prepare each meal.
  8. I will take pictures of every meal I eat, and keep a record of what that meal is.
  9. I will take a picture of any food that is left at the end.
  10. I will try to budget my food consumption, so the food lasts the entire 5 days.
  11. I will only eat what I purchase (no additional food bought, accepted or consumed)
  12. If I become weak, or I run out of most foods, I will sensibly stop (ex. If only oatmeal is left by day 5, I stop!).
Skip to toolbar