I think that this movie really opened my eyes to how education really is around the world. I am very new to this subject and have had not had much experience with many of these topics, but I feel like I have learned a lot in a short amount of time about how education works around the world. A very interesting topic that I saw and feel comes from Western thinking is the invention of failure.
It seemed that in the Indian culture there was a high value placed on being educated and making it through to a high level of education. As the movie progressed there was a sense that many of these kids that started going to school do not make it through and then consider themselves failures. As one of the men said in the movie, that these kids will refer to themselves as failures for the rest of their lives. I think the idea of failing in school really is a Western idea, putting grades and evaluating every aspect of education. There is much more to life than grades and how high you make it through the education chain. It was interesting to see how the elders in the community viewed schooling. Some of the women that have been in the village their whole lives and have made major contributions to the well being of the whole community, are considered to be uneducated and of lesser value to society. They are living the simple life that they grew up with, and find it hard to see the value in leaving their rich culture to try and go after money and big jobs. These ideas being implanted by aid organizations and other influences trying to promote Western education ideas. Shields quotes Samoff and Brock- Utne saying, “A major critique of international development programmes is that they reflect the interests and priorities of donor organizations rather than those of aid recipients” (Shields 40). If they don’t achieve these goals set then they are considered failures and return to their village and in turn do not know how to do anything on the land. They lose their roots and the culture that their elders have believed in so strongly throughout their lives. These cultural values are just as important as being well educated, and there is a gap between education and culture that needs to be fixed.
I think that overall that many kids and young adults in other countries are being negatively effected by the Western education ideals that are being forced on them. They are being told that they need to be doctors and lawyers, and to make a lot of money to be happy and considered a success. Many of these people will not attain these lofty goals, and in the process lose their cultural values as well.